
After some discussions while I skitter around trying to figure out my thoughts regarding Crimes of Grindelwald, I have decided to post How To guides for plotting purposes. I shall start with the easiest one – Abernathy.
Abernathy’s history was designed very specifically, as I wanted to use him from the very beginning as a means of challenging the idea that Percival Graves –
Director of Magical Security and Head of Magical Law Enforcement – overall Very Public Figure – was impersonated without anybody noticing, or any follow up being taken to find out what the fuck happened to Graves, anyway? Because we know from Goblet of Fire you need a living human for Polyjuice to work.
He is an ambitious person and one with very complex loyalties – the kind that can get pretty disastrous pretty fast, given that he has a do whatever it takes attitude when it comes to defending those who have managed to earn that loyalty. He is fastidious, and extremely goal and rule oriented which doesn’t make for the best personality sometimes, but ultimately speaking his heart is usually in the right place he just doesn’t know when to stop.
The fandom was hugely anti-Abernathy when I first started writing him, prompting his original url to be fuckyouabernathy – and yes, that url still belongs to me, and no, I will not be relinquishing it so long as I live. That said, due to how virulent some of the things could get, I did incorporate an element of that hatred into his character because I felt it was pretty important to touch on.
Between that, the very misconstrued ‘oh good gravy’ moment being labelled as this idea he was Hot For Queenie and the idea that he’s So Damn Awful To Tina as if there aren’t completely justifiable reasons for his frustration AND FOR HERS – I was pretty nervous about what the movie was going to do with my son who – considering he didn’t even get a first name in Film One – I had kiiinda hoped would be a throwaway character I could do what I wanted with forever and nobody could stop me.
So imagine my IMMENSE SURPRISE AND DELIGHT when I realized the following.
From day ONE I have had a verse where Abernathy – being seen as a nosy desk jockey with no prospects and even less threat but a Prestigious Family Line – manages to weasel his way into helping Grindelwald because he wants to find Percival Graves despite knowing that Graves himself would be livid that he aided and abetted a war criminal to achieve it.
ABERNATHY IS FUCKING SMART. He isn’t going to reveal himself until he has Graves and can bring him back. He is willing to sacrifice his career for it because partly, its the right thing to do in his strange little head but also, because he feels guilty – he liked Graves well enough, and I do headcanon that while Graves never really gave Abernathy the time of day, he was never outrightly cruel either.
Mainly cause Abernathy barely even registered to him, lets be real. They had a positive working relationship because Graves didn’t see much in Abernathy beyond a strong work ethic, and Abernathy liked Graves because he was efficient, good at his job, allowed Abernathy to do his job, and was never an outright asshole.
But the idea that nobody noticed – the idea that he had been hoodwinked as well, that he had allowed Graves to suffer who knows what because he hadn’t paid enough attention – well it triggers him right into that loyalty issue he has with his brother. He immediately has to understand and to fix it and to somehow show Graves he has someone in his corner.
So having him lose his own tongue to aid Gellert Grindelwald in escaping MACUSA custody – having him act like a quiet and supportive burr to Grindelwald – makes perfect sense for my portrayal. He wants to be close enough to Grindelwald to discover where Graves is – but also obscure enough to Grindelwald to never present himself as a threat, because he doesn’t stand a snowballs chance in hell.
Kid knows his strengths, and going toe to toe with Grindelwald is not gonna happen. But yes – in short, Abernathy remains loyal to Graves and to his Own Sense Of Right – he is not a Grindelwald fanatic, he is not a follower – but he is a very determined kind of dumbass. And if you’re wondering how he fooled the fire, well it all ties to the fact I write him as an occlumens.
Plotting wise, this can go a lot of places because he IS contemptuous of MACUSA and he is bitterly angry and upset on Graves’ behalf. On the other hand Grindelwald is everything Graves opposes so he’s in a pickle that could make him susceptible to people like Tina or Queenie or Newt if they hit him upside the head with a shoe made of better logic.